AGILEAN TM

Outcomes

Approach

Resources

Corporate

 
Information Driven

Home > Resources > Lean Office FAQ > Lean Office Principles

 

AGILEAN Newsletter

Follow the Money Blog

Lean Office FAQ

Recommended Reading

Articles

 
 

Lean Office FAQ:  Performance Principles

1. What is the purpose of performance principles?

2. What kind of questions do performance principles answer?

3. How do performance principles maximize value?

4. Do performance principles already exist in the organization?

5. What is the approach for developing performance principles?

6. What are performance principle pitfalls?

 

1. What is the purpose of performance principles?

The Lean Office Glossary defines performance principles as a rule or standard used to align day-to-day tactical decision making with organizational strategy and value propositions. Value statements establish worth; a principle is a standard for achieving that worth. If values are the what; principles are the how.

Principles, when universally shared by an organization, enable effective decision making. They are intended to be used as guidelines to enable decision making at the lowest possible level. As guidelines they are not a replacement for decision making. Exceptions to principles are expected to occur.

The goal for any principle is that it can be applied 80% of the time. The other 20% are handled as exceptions on a case by case basis. This may seem like principles are not adding value. But with solid principles, only 20% of the cases are treated like exceptions. Most organizations without performance principles treat all cases (100%) as exceptions. Under the best conditions, making the same decision from scratch every time. Or worse, making inconsistent decisions from case to case.

Performance principles are important to Lean Office because Lean requires employees take an active role in maximizing value and minimizing waste. In a factory setting, understanding value and waste creation is a much more straight forward proposition. In an office setting where there is considerable more flexibility and labor content, performance principles provide the necessary underlying framework before Lean concepts can be successfully applied.

Top

2. What kind of questions do performance principles answer?

Performance principles are all about how a value is to be achieved. Performance principles answer the following questions (80% of the time):

  • When is an action or behavior appropriate?
  • When or how should the decision be made?
  • What is the appropriate guideline for an action or behavior?
  • What should you or your staff do?
  • What are the words to live by?
  • What should be known before making a decision?
  • How should the action or behavior be accomplished?

 

Top

3. How do performance principles maximize value?

Performance principles maximize value when they guide the formation of Lean Office value streams. Take for example an order processing value stream. Assume the value priorities for order processing is to create a buying experience that maximizes customer satisfaction, while also minimizing the cycle time to recognize the revenue. Value priorities do not provide guidelines for how this is to be accomplished. That is the purpose of performance principles.

An example of a performance principle in the order processing scenario could be "We will accept changes to any customer order up until the time it is shipped." This principle focuses on the buying experience and makes clear what could otherwise be a source of confusion within the order entry department. Every activity of the value stream can now be optimized to help insure this principle is fulfilled. Without this principle each activity owner of the value stream could interpret maximizing the customer buying experience in a different way - leading to an inconsistent and disjointed buying experience.

Top

4. Do performance principles already exist in the organization?

Whether or not management has formally identified performance principles they already exist in the organization. Every individual uses performance principles as guidelines for decision making. Without a formal set, performance principles are adopted informally from:

  • This is the way we have always done it
  • This is what my (manager, customer, friend) told me yesterday
  • This is the best thing for (the company, the customer, me)
  • This is what they do at (Wall-Mart, Dell, Southwest Airlines)

It is not the lack of performance principles that hurts most organizations. It is the vast number of them shared unequally by many different stakeholders that causes conflicts in every day decision making. Is a new or existing customer more important? Who owns the customer? When is it appropriate to say no to a customer? Any one answer to these questions is probably OK. Having key individuals in the organization competing with conflicting answers to these questions can be disastrous.

Top

5. What is the approach for developing performance principles?

The prerequisites for developing performance principles are mission, vision. and value statements. These serve to set the tone of the organization, where it is going, and how it is going to get there. Performance principles form the link between these statements of value and the tactical day-to-day. If mission, vision, and value statements are missing or fail to cover the current strategy of the entire organization, they must be updated prior to developing performance principles.

Value statements by definition apply to the entire organization. Performance principles can be developed as part of a hierarchical model. Value statements say what, performance principles say how. The how can be different based on the segment or level of the organization they are applied. Performance principles can be developed once for the entire organization. Or they can be developed both at a corporate level and a departmental level. In the latter example, certain corporate principles might still apply at the department, and others may be different for each. This makes sense because the how at the corporate level can be different than the how for human resources or customer service.

Performance principles are developed for each value statement. If an organization has 7-10 value statements, performance principles would be developed indicating how that value is to be realized. There is no formula for the number of performance principles per value statement. It's generally a good idea to not have more than 7-10. If it appears more are needed then the principles may be a too low a level or the value statement needs to be split into two statements.

The preferred approach to developing performance principles is to do it with all of the key stakeholders in the room. A facilitated brainstorming session works the best. Engaging in a discussion about how the organization is going to achieve its values can sometimes be very lively. An independent facilitator can maintain everyone's involvement while insuring the discussion remains focused on developing a working principle.

Top

6. What are performance principle pitfalls?

  1. Expecting the process to be easy - Just as developing mission, vision, and value statements can be a difficult process to undertake, the same follows for performance principles. Performance principles are the next layer of the strategic onion. Engaging stakeholders in defining principles as guidelines for how the strategy is to be executed, naturally exposes soft areas in the strategy and differences in how the strategy is perceived.

  2. Apple pie principles - Performance principles need to be specific enough that they can influence behavior. The statement: "We listen to our customers" does not provide sufficient instruction in exactly how that is to be achieved. A more actionable principle might be "We proactively ask for input, we actively listen, and we give specific feedback that demonstrates we heard."

  3. Too few from the top - Performance principles help align every day decision making with the values of the organization. Too few principles set at the top and symptoms of misaligned value priorities begin to appear. Starting to ship poor quality products? Check principles associated with quality and meeting customer ship dates.

  4. Boiling the ocean - Principles are a means for management to communicate guidelines to follow while achieving strategic objectives. Provide the organization too many principles and communication fails. It becomes impossible to use principles as decision guidelines because there are too many sign posts to follow.

  5. Future state principles - Performance principles are guidelines for today. They are not about how the organization wants to be some time in the future. Principles are all about making the best decisions given current circumstances. Later when circumstances change, the principles can change. Creating principles that cannot be followed leads to frustration and waste. If there is no budget for training, create a principle that eliminates training. Use principles to focus the organization on what can be accomplished and revisit training when money is available.

Top

Copyright 2008 © AGILEAN Corporation.  All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy  |  Site Map  |  Contact Us